Strategic Procurement: Building Win-Win Alliances Between Sponsor and CDMO

Procurement leaders told CDMO Live Americas how better RFPs, shared incentives and two-way governance turn CDMO contracts into lasting alliances.

“We measure OTIF down to the decimal point, but we don’t even know if we trust each other.” Daniel Marasco said he once heard that line from a colleague, and it sums up a problem in many outsourcing relationships: the performance metrics are precise, but the trust behind them is weak.

Marasco is a biopharma supply chain and external manufacturing leader who has worked at Merck, BMS, Shire and Takeda. He spoke on a panel at CDMO Live Americas 2026 in Boston with Frederik Krekeler, Head of Procurement Consumer Health North America at Bayer; Susan Camden, Vice President of Business Development at Kindeva; and Lindsay Pope, Founder of Apothecary Consulting.

Transactional Deals in Partnership Clothing

Camden opened by pushing back on the session’s own title. “We say win-win. I say give and take is probably a better phrase for it,” she said. Her biggest red flag is a relationship that is “clearly transactional under the guise of strategic partnership”: the sponsor asks for great pricing now and offers a vague promise of more products later. Kindeva has walked away from customers like that.

“A good CDMO that you actually want handling your product isn’t desperate,” she said. “If you get this low price, and everything seems too good to be true, it probably is. There’s nothing more expensive than having problems or timeline issues or people making promises that they can’t keep.”

At Bayer, how strategic a supplier is depends partly on how much the company spends with it, but spend is only one factor. Strategic partners co-invest, share a roadmap and have “skin in the game” on product launches. Krekeler added a caveat: “Strategic partners are not exempt from the cost discipline.” That matters in a cost-competitive over-the-counter market and during inflation spikes.

Rewriting the RFP

Pope argued that most RFPs are boilerplate checklists covering financials, capacity and certifications. “The real meat of it is whether or not they can fix something when it happens,” she said. “Something is going to go wrong, and that’s okay.”

To find out, she asks bidders to list their customers from a date range she chooses, then contacts those customers directly. “I don’t shy away from a negative answer. I want to know what happened, how did they react, how did they respond.” She also debriefs losing bidders so they can bid better next time.

Contracts That Reward the Upside

Most CDMO contracts penalize poor performance. The panel wanted contracts that also reward good performance. Marasco would pay for on-time-in-full and right-first-time delivery measured over six to 12 months, because both cut the sponsor’s expediting and batch review costs. He also described a “yield bank”: when a CDMO beats its yield target, for example by hitting 96% against 95%, it banks the extra point as credit against a future shortfall.

Camden asked that efficiencies a CDMO uncovers be shared with it and not handed entirely to the sponsor. “Any time you can pull us in so that we both mutually benefit, you’re always going to get people to run harder for you.” Pope recommended escalation clauses and clearly defined partnership tiers. These let a new supplier earn more work, better rates or rebates as it proves itself.

Governance Built for Disruption

Marasco pairs standard KPIs with a 360 survey held once or twice a year. Both sides rate the relationship and compare where their views differ. When a CDMO runs into trouble, he wants sponsors to commit resources. “If the supplier fails, we’re going to fail,” he said. “Don’t send 10 people there just asking when it is going to be fixed. Send two people that can actually fix it.”

Camden urged sponsors to ask CDMOs during evaluation to “show me your tools”, meaning the systems they use to share status, risks and documents with customers. When tensions involving Iran threatened resin supply, Kindeva alerted its auto-injector and metered-dose inhaler customers before any action was needed. Pope described the opposite: a vendor that had not heard about a supply risk until she called. She dropped that vendor.

Leaving Well

Krekeler said exits and transfers happen often, as CDMOs change ownership and sponsors’ portfolios change. Bayer communicates early, manages transitions fairly and holds partners accountable for write-offs, because “you might see each other again.” Camden agreed: “Leave well, and it’ll always come back to you.”

What Every Contract Should Include

When asked what they would add to every CDMO contract, the panelists gave practical answers. Krekeler wants reciprocal feedback and in-person quarterly reviews: “Being a good customer also means you listen.” Marasco wants a commitment to continuous improvement with resources from both sides. Camden wants the contract to set out how the two sides negotiate, so deals move faster. For outsourcing leaders, the message was simple: sponsors who pay fairly and listen get CDMOs that prioritize them when it matters.

Download ‘Partnerships Under Pressure’ the full report from CDMO Live Americas for 102 pages of outsourcing insights